Why Vinyl Records are Becoming Popular Again

February 19, 2010 at 1:26 am 4 comments

By Chad Upton | Editor

There have always been cool record shops in the hip parts of town hocking vinyl to the enthusiasts. But, it had been a long time since the major record stores carried them, until last year.

Maybe you’ve noticed, maybe not. But if you’ve been into BestBuy recently, some of their stores have a massive vinyl record selection. A year ago, they had a few, now they have hundreds. It’s not every store, but some of them.


Vinyl Edition


For many people, it’s probably hard to imagine that anyone would go back to using records.

Records are not convenient to use. They don’t play for very long, about 26 minutes before you have to flip it over or put a new one on. You can’t easily skip songs at the push of a button. They have to be kept very clean to sound good. The needle drags on the record so the sound degrades over time and worst of all, they are expensive.

Since all of these drawbacks are easily overcome by digital formats like CDs and MP3s, it surely makes people wonder, why are vinyl records making a mainstream comeback?

It’s a good question and to understand the answer, we have to know a little bit about the difference between digital and analog recordings.

Digital recordings are great because the data doesn’t change over time. You can playback a CD or MP3 thousands of times and it will sound exactly the same every time. But, although that recording is the same every time, it’s not necessarily a perfect representation of the live music that it is a recording of.

Most musical instruments are analog, when a guitar string is plucked or a drum is hit, that object vibrates at a certain speed, causing an analog sound wave to travel across the room and make your eardrum vibrate. Our brain interprets that vibration as sound. In a recording, that sound is received by a microphone and recorded. During playback, that information is turned back into sound waves when your speakers vibrate. Speakers are rated in quality by their ability to vibrate exactly like the instruments did that made the original sound in the recording.

On a CD or in an MP3s, there are no such thing as waves. Everything is recorded as a one or zero. So, to make waves, they stores lots of ones and zeros for every second of music (44,100/second on a CD). These ones and zeros approximately represent the original wave that was produced by the vibrating guitar string. The key part of that is “approximately.” If you’ve ever tried to make a round object with LEGO, you know what I mean. You can get it to look almost round, but it’s not perfect, it’s kind of jagged.

Digital recordings are also jagged. Digital players have an analog to digital converter that tries to guess what the wave form would have looked like, based on the jagged forms that are made with the digital data. Because there are so many ones and zeros, it sounds almost exactly like the original recording and some players are better than others at filling in those gaps.


The XX - Vinyl Edition


But, our ears are not digital. Our ears are analog. When you get your ear next to a real instrument and pluck its strings or press its keys, you hear a timbre, a texture in the sound that is very difficult to reproduce. There are subtleties and nuances that often get lost in recordings.

Record enthusiasts like analog recordings because they more closely represent sound in the way that our hearing works. If you use an analog amplifier, there is no digital to analog conversion, making the experience very similar to being at the live recording.

Records are also large (up to 12 inches in diameter) and maybe they only play for 26 minutes and show their age over time. But, that has a certain romance, like a hand written letter instead of an email. Email has its obvious benefits, but when you get a hand written letter, it is special.

Records are not for everyone and they’re not for every situation. I don’t expect to see portable record players any time soon and I wouldn’t give up my MP3 player either.

Bonus Secrets: The Olympic Medals in the photo in yesterday’s post are the medals won by Nancy Greene in the 1968 Winter Olympics. She also carried the Vancouver 2010 torch when it passed through Kamloops, BC.

Broken Secrets

Subscribe on: Facebook | Twitter | Kindle

Entry filed under: Around The House, Demystified, Gadgets and Toys, Geek. Tags: , , , , , , .

How Much is the Gold in an Olympic Medal Worth? Botox can be Prescribed by Your Doctor

4 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Richard K. Duck  |  February 19, 2010 at 1:38 am

    C’mon, gimme a break. Us baby boomers appreciate the before tecnology scene invaded our “Happy Days”. I have all my 45 RPMS & albums from when I was young. NOt only the original good music but the memories of playing them with friends. And don’t forget all the dances that used to go with them. The Swim, the Twist….
    I have a juke box for the old 45s and love it.
    I try to play my CD player and it is not as easy….itty bitty buttons black against black. The old record players were easy for a blind mand (I’m almost there at my age,lol).
    Trivia: How many grooves on a 45 RPM record?

    • 2. Chad Upton  |  February 23, 2010 at 11:25 pm

      Richard, you make a great point, although I don’t know a lot of people in your generation who still buy LPs, apart from a few audiophiles who are into Classical and Jazz.

      But you’re right, nostalgia is an important part of records.

      1 groove in a 45.

  • 3. Ted  |  May 2, 2016 at 3:27 pm

    Great article! One observation, portable 45 record players have been around at least since the 80’s.

  • 4. Rachel Lannister  |  March 13, 2017 at 12:59 pm

    Thanks for the very informative read. I like what you said about how vinyl records are able to pick up sounds, textures and timbres that digital simply can’t capture. I’ll have to find a place where I can find some good records. That way, I can enjoy music like I was hearing it live.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Follow Broken Secrets

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,365 other subscribers

Big Awards

Best Personal Blog/Website (People's Voice)

W3 Award - Copy Writing


Featured by…

• Yahoo
• Business Insider
• Smithsonian Magazine
• USA Today
• AskMen (and many more...)

Contact Info

%d bloggers like this: